AI and work beyond the slogans: BBC revisits the Luddites with Brian Merchant
Before asking whether artificial intelligence threatens democracy, it is worth returning to workers who feared losing their livelihoods and autonomy to new machines: that is the perspective of BBC News’ conversation with journalist and author Brian Merchant.
The video belongs to The Global Backstory, The Global Story’s strand exploring the history behind the news, and uses England’s nineteenth-century Luddites to examine the present.
## More than “enemies of progress”
In the BBC’s presentation, Merchant challenges the reduction of those textile workers to people who could not understand technology: livelihoods and the transformation of work were central concerns.
The National Archives provides a useful cross-check: workers protested against employers using machines to replace skilled labour and drive down wages.
Its account documents petitions, public protests and letters to officials alongside the destruction of machinery, and dates the beginning of the disturbances in Nottinghamshire to 1811.
That range of actions is more informative than a label used as an insult.
## A conversation, not a prediction
The video’s chapters move from textile workers’ lives to the AI revolution and its potential social consequences.
The comparison with the present is the speakers’ interpretive framework, not proof that history must repeat itself or that AI inevitably produces a particular political regime.
A more practical question for viewers is who decides how a technology is introduced and who gets a say in its consequences.
The original comes from the official BBC News channel: YouTube’s timestamp is 18 November 2026 at 15:15:11 with an offset of -08:00, equivalent to 19 November at 00:15:11 in Italy, before this edition’s cutoff.
The player metadata permits embedding, although the local playback test returned configuration error 153; that failure does not establish a rights-holder prohibition.
The original link remains available and should be preferred to unverified copies or reuploads.
