Letting other people surprise us
Someone close to us turns down an invitation. The explanation is ready: ‘They never want to spend time with us.’ But can one answer today really tell us who a person is? This column asks what happens when the labels we give others leave them no room to surprise us.
The starting point is ‘L’amore si impara’ (‘Love can be learned’), an article by Patrizio Paoletti dated 19 January 2021, found through his blog and read in full.
The author encourages readers to reconsider the label they have attached to another person and to revise their assumptions in response to that person’s sensitivity.
This is a personal, philosophical perspective, not clinical evidence. We take only that invitation from the piece; we do not adopt its broader claims about the power of one’s inner attitude.
## A person is not their part in our story
What follows is the editorial team’s own reflection. We may have known someone for years and still describe them as ‘the one who never organises anything’, ‘the confident one’ or ‘the one who never needs help’. The question we propose is not just whether the description is fair, but whether it still allows us to notice something new.
Consider an invented scene, not an experience attributed to Vittorio or an episode from the source. A family member regarded as uninterested in celebrations suggests a simple lunch. Someone replies: ‘You? Since when?’ Surprise can be affectionate; it can also become a gate if every initiative must first pass the test of an old role.
Our suggestion is to welcome the gesture before commenting on how unusual it is: ‘What did you have in mind?’ That does not mean pretending the past never happened. It means not requiring someone to remain consistent with the character we have assigned them.
## A more precise sentence, not compulsory trust
Readers who wish to can take one habitual label and rewrite it as a specific observation: from ‘you are unreliable’ to ‘last time, you did not let me know you would be late’. This is an optional editorial invitation, not Paoletti’s method or a therapeutic technique. The second sentence does not erase the problem: it gives it a date and a behaviour rather than allowing it to occupy someone’s entire identity.
Making room for surprise does not require us to disregard repeated conduct, abandon boundaries or renew trust when the conditions are absent. Not everything depends on the story we tell ourselves about a relationship: the other person’s actions matter too. In our view, openness and caution can belong in the same sentence.
The aim is not to learn to see everyone positively. It is to be able to say ‘this is what I know so far’ without turning it into ‘this is everything you are’. A small form of respect, with no promise of guaranteed wellbeing. [Paoletti’s original Italian article](https://patriziopaoletti.it/lamore-si-impara/) remains available to distinguish his voice from ours.
