Mushroom soup: four tablespoons to keep out of the blender

Pause before blending: four tablespoons of mushrooms should be set aside. That small instruction is the focus of our reading of Il Cucchiaio d'Argento's mushroom soup, because some of the pan's contents return to the bowl without going through the blender.
This is an original culinary reading of a recipe consulted in full, not a newly invented recipe or a kitchen test conducted by this newsroom.

## Ingredients for four
The source specifies 500 g of cleaned mixed mushrooms, 500 ml vegetable stock, 100 ml fresh cream, 30 ml Marsala, 20 g butter and 4 shallots.
Fresh thyme, extra-virgin olive oil, salt and pepper complete the list, without numerical quantities for these finishing ingredients.
Its suggested cultivated mix includes oyster mushrooms, pioppini and button mushrooms; we stay with that approach rather than turning the recipe into foraging advice.
The mushroom weight is for the cleaned ingredient, not an amount still needing trimming.

## Make two different textures
Start by cutting the mushrooms into medium slices and finely slicing the shallots; soften the shallots in the melted butter in a saucepan.
Add the mushrooms, brown them well and reserve four tablespoons for the final garnish.
Our reading follows those two paths: most of the mushrooms form the smooth base, while a small portion remains identifiable on top.

Add hot stock and cream to the mushrooms in the pan and bring to the boil; cover and cook gently for 20 minutes, stirring occasionally.
Season with salt and pepper, add the Marsala and then use an immersion blender to obtain a smooth cream.
The source adds the wine after that cooking stage, not during the initial browning; we make no claim that the alcohol is completely removed.

## The simmer is not the whole cooking time
The recipe card gives 15 minutes of preparation and 25 minutes of cooking, whereas the method's 20 minutes refer specifically to the covered, gentle cooking stage.
These are not competing instructions: browning and bringing the liquid to the boil precede that stage.
No oven temperature applies: this is a saucepan recipe, specifying a boil followed by gentle heat rather than a numerical temperature.
Its stated timings also assume stock is available and the mushrooms have already been cleaned, as the ingredient list specifies.

Ladle the blended soup into bowls and finish with the reserved mushrooms, freshly ground pepper, thyme leaves and a drizzle of olive oil.
The editorial point is the decision not to make every element uniform, rather than an unsupported health promise or an invented historical tradition.
[Read Il Cucchiaio d'Argento's full recipe](https://www.cucchiaio.it/ricetta/vellutata-funghi/).

Report article

Back to WebSuggestion home

Cookie preferences