Burnham prepares Brexit criticism, but closer EU ties do not mean a decided return
Andy Burnham is preparing an explicit criticism of Brexit’s results, but closer relations with the European Union are not being presented as a decision to rejoin.
Il Post describes the speech planned for the evening of 16 November in London using extracts circulated in advance by the prime minister’s office.
At this edition’s 19:00 Italian cutoff, the account concerns those advance extracts; it does not certify that the speech has already been delivered.
## The political judgement in the extracts
Reuters, read on Chronicle.lu, attributes to the advance text the claim that the Brexit inherited by the government has not worked and that the UK has lost more than it gained.
That is the political judgement Burnham is preparing to express, not a new economic estimate produced by this publication.
The agency also describes his wish to reopen a broader discussion of the deal negotiated by the previous Conservative government.
A different tone does not, by itself, change the legal relationship with the EU.
## Three tests and an original document
Reuters reports that a future agreement should respect Labour’s manifesto and red lines, improve the previous deal and deliver tangible benefits in daily life.
The original «Britain reconnected» manifesto chapter rules out a return to the single market, the customs union and freedom of movement; it instead proposes removing unnecessary trade barriers and negotiating a veterinary agreement.
This party document is the primary source for those commitments, not a transcript of today’s speech or proof that a new agreement has been concluded.
## Negotiations still lie ahead
Il Post dates the next Brussels meeting with António Costa and Ursula von der Leyen to 20 November.
Reuters lists reduced checks on food and agricultural products and easier youth mobility among the expected outcomes: these remain negotiating objectives, not rights already available.
Chronicle’s text nevertheless contains the inconsistent date «Friday’20 December», while the rest of the report refers to Friday of the same week; the 20 November date used here is attributed to Il Post, rather than silently correcting the other source.
The political issue is the room Burnham seeks between criticism of leaving the EU and the constraints of his manifesto. The next stage should be judged against negotiated documents, not advance rhetoric alone.
