Love does not entitle us to a password

A phone can remain private even within an important relationship. Tonight’s question is not how much we should share, but whether sharing still leaves room for a choice.

The starting point is Patrizio Paoletti’s “La Legge dell’amore”, published on 7 March 2022 and selected after consulting his blog: an archive piece newly used in this column, not an article released today.
Paoletti describes love as a presence that brings us closer to another person and connects relationships with a shared path of transformation.
That is the author’s philosophical perspective, not something we present as scientific proof.

**Our original editorial reflection begins here.** We turn to an issue we do not attribute to Paoletti: the difference between closeness and access. Understanding someone is not the same as being able to read every message on their phone. A relationship need not operate like an archive with every folder open.

Imagine a couple discussing location sharing. “This will prove you trust me” turns the decision into a test. In our hypothetical scene, a different question would be: “What situation would we need this for, and can we also decide not to use it?” This is not a guaranteed script. It is a way to make a request open to discussion rather than treating it as a settled decision.

**Permission has a scope.** Sharing a location during a journey does not necessarily mean wanting to share it every day. In the approach we suggest, lending a device to look up an address is not an invitation to browse conversations. People can agree on a specific purpose and revisit that agreement without treating a change of mind as an accusation.

The question also concerns the person receiving access: do we actually need it? Before asking for a password, we might consider whether we want practical information or reassurance that no screen can ever make permanent. We are not proposing secrecy about shared commitments, but questioning whether complete exposure should be the price of affection.

This reflection is not an invitation to remain in a controlling or threatening situation. It does not make the person experiencing it responsible for solving it through better communication. It is neither therapy nor personal testimony. Our editorial criterion is narrower: closeness can also mean respecting what another person chooses not to hand over.

Report article

Back to WebSuggestion home

Cookie preferences