Italy’s Chamber passes antisemitism bill as the IHRA definition divides the opposition
Italy’s Chamber of Deputies completed its examination of the antisemitism bill on 17 November: the Chamber’s official announcement confirms approval of the text previously passed by the Senate.
The tally was 147 in favour, 93 against and five abstentions, according to matching reports by Sky TG24 and Il Post.
Beyond the parliamentary outcome, the political divide concerns the standard used to identify and counter hatred of Jews, particularly when public debate concerns Israel.
## A definition and an institutional framework
The five-article text adopts the working definition formulated by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance in 2016; its first article also refers to respect for constitutional freedoms.
The Chamber’s research service describes a three-year national strategy, adopted by the Council of Ministers on the national coordinator’s proposal, to prevent antisemitism and strengthen social cohesion and the security of Jewish communities.
Article 3 sets out action against prejudice and stereotypes; Article 4 provides for a coordinator appointed by prime-ministerial decree and supported by a technical working group.
Article 5 contains a budget-neutrality clause.
Sky and Il Post explain that the bill creates no new criminal offences: the dispute therefore also concerns the effects of a statutory reference in preventive and institutional work, rather than criminal law alone.
## Opposition parties take different sides
Azione and Italia Viva supported the governing parties, while the Democratic Party, Five Star Movement and Green and Left Alliance voted against; five MPs abstained.
Il Post notes that the Democratic Party had abstained during the Senate’s first reading, making its opposition in the Chamber a different position at this stage.
Critics cited by the newspaper argue that the definition could blur the distinction between antisemitism and legitimate criticism of Israeli policies.
That is a stated concern, not evidence that every criticism of Israel is now prohibited.
## Competing assessments of free-expression safeguards
Sky reports that Ucei president Livia Ottolenghi welcomed the measure as strengthening democratic safeguards and protecting freedom of criticism.
The same report records Amnesty International’s opposing concern about censorship and self-censorship in schools, universities and other settings.
These positions address how the framework may operate: neither reassurance nor alarm is already an assessment of observed implementation.
Parliamentary passage is the established outcome; this account does not establish publication in Italy’s Official Gazette or an entry-into-force date.
